Opinion Poll
Patriotic Indians
Another new state Telangana !!
Hot Threads
Sunder R Chitturi Ya I am with you on that! it is a sad day. It is just sending a wrong message to all the hooligans out there. It is a sad day. more
Vimal Kumar This is Unfortunate that people who don't know about Telangana struggle are saying this not a right decision.......I want you to look into the reali.. more
Topic owner: Megha Talwar: Just read the news about Govt giving a go ahead to Telangana, i am shocked on how the govt. has given up on the issue, as a result there will be another state,
Dont know if creating more states will help India or be anti national integration.
I feel its not in the country's interest. What do you feel guys?
Dont know if creating more states will help India or be anti national integration.
I feel its not in the country's interest. What do you feel guys?
Vineet Bindal
WELL , i HAVE BEEN READING ABAUT THIS TALANGANA ISSUE FROM MANY DAYS, I HAVE DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH AND ON THE BACKGROUND. AI CAN NOT SAY FOR SURE WHY IT WAS NOT FORMED BEFORE, BUT RIGHT NOW IT IS ALL POLITICS. SPECIALLY BY PEOPLE LIKE KCR, THESE GUYS SHOULD NOT EVEN BE PART OF POLITICS, WHY DONT SOMEONE KILL THESE KIND OF PEOPLE,
ALL THE INTELLIGENT PEOPLE WHO ARE SUPPORTING TALANGANA AND SAYING THAT IT IS STILL A PART OF INDIA, I ASK YOU ONE THING HOW ABOUT IF SOME MUSLIM MEJORITY PARTS IN UP AND BIHAR STARTS SAYING THAT GIVE US ARE SAPERATE MUSLIM STATES, BECOUSE WE HAVE NOT BEEN DEVELOPED AND NEGLECTED BY THE GOVT. WILL YOU UNDERSTAND AT THAT POINT THAT , THESE THINGS DOES MATTER TO THE INTEGRITY.
NO PROBLEM CAN WITHSTAND THE RIGHT APPROACH, AND SEPARATING STATES IS NO RIGHT WAY,
ALL THE INTELLIGENT PEOPLE WHO ARE SUPPORTING TALANGANA AND SAYING THAT IT IS STILL A PART OF INDIA, I ASK YOU ONE THING HOW ABOUT IF SOME MUSLIM MEJORITY PARTS IN UP AND BIHAR STARTS SAYING THAT GIVE US ARE SAPERATE MUSLIM STATES, BECOUSE WE HAVE NOT BEEN DEVELOPED AND NEGLECTED BY THE GOVT. WILL YOU UNDERSTAND AT THAT POINT THAT , THESE THINGS DOES MATTER TO THE INTEGRITY.
NO PROBLEM CAN WITHSTAND THE RIGHT APPROACH, AND SEPARATING STATES IS NO RIGHT WAY,
Ram Prasad
People who want Telengana List out all the fictional injustice meted out to them. If they feel they are not being given enough water from Andhra Now, when they are a unified state, what makes them think they will get more water when they are separate ! If there is injustice, fight for justice not for splitting states, people and spilling blood. And never trust any blog which has facts underlined, they are neither relevant facts nor are they unbiased.
Ram Prasad
We should have a Government Body Working for Unity of People,
searching ways to bridge us, not for State Restructuring
Committees(SRC) to split India into bits for the Rs.1 Lakh Crores
Allocated by Govenment for the formation each of these states. It is
all about money pocketed by few, by exploiting innocent, illiterate
people by whipping up passion and pride.
searching ways to bridge us, not for State Restructuring
Committees(SRC) to split India into bits for the Rs.1 Lakh Crores
Allocated by Govenment for the formation each of these states. It is
all about money pocketed by few, by exploiting innocent, illiterate
people by whipping up passion and pride.
Ram Prasad
In 1934 Henry Miller wrote "Wherever there are ten Hindus together there is India with her sects and schisms, her racial, lingual, religious, political antagonisms. In the person of Gandhi they are experiencing for a brief moment the miracle of unity, but when he goes there will be a crash, an utter relapse into that strife and chaos so characteristic of the Indian people." His Book was Banned In India. Yes, if you think splitting India into 30,000 pieces and spilling blood for meaningless smaller states, go ahead it is just your children's future you don't care about. Do not talk about justifying meaningless struggles.
Madhav Kadam
Today we are living in21st century,it is the need of time to be free or seperated and help our country to become a developed one.Gone are the days when our eminent politicians and social workers fought for india as a united nation. India is a country known as unity in diversity. The freedom of seperation should be given not only Telangana but also all the parts who want to be seperated.There should be a fixed criteria according to the geographical location. The ultimate power should be in the hands of central government. The responsibility of work will teach everything to the newly born such states in india. Why we indian people making issues and loss before the creation of such states. Giving responsibility of freedom will teach every such states and they will ultimately responsible for their loss and gain.So freedom should be given them with power and honour.
Ritesh Mahashabde
only people benifit from smaller states are politicians like madhu koda
36 states 36 CM , (their never ending ministry and appetite for money), 360 regional parties and a hung parliament followed by coalition govt at center for all
36 states 36 CM , (their never ending ministry and appetite for money), 360 regional parties and a hung parliament followed by coalition govt at center for all
Ashok Munikuntla
The Cry for Samaikyandhra at this stage is the Cry of Exploiters on denial of grip over the Exploited. The Exploiters want the suppressed to remain suppressed for their own comforts and luxuries.
Naresh Chowdhary G..
i strongly feel our nation need not democracy, but dectatorship. there must stamp out Vandalism and grafity some how..otherwise oneday we have to bow to next nations prior to defence or something else more serious. this is why because the unity of indians or fellow regioners found to be selfish..the state govt lake of prompt leader n always left decisions headed to center n those people were lack of knowledge on the ground issues whereby. this is where current emergency occurs..i'm sure this congress govt been failed in that scenario. should have conceal those assumptions made while the 3states added in the past.
Basil Pereira
History has not taught a lesson to us Indians. In the past we have been destroyed as a nation because of our communal politics and allowed ourselves to be ruled by the Muslim rulers and then the Christian. Today, we are breaking our country into small parts. Why will some nation not take advantage of the same due to our mindsets and we becoming slaves for the next 500 yrs till another MAHATMA GANDHI arrives?
Ravi Gupta
I believe Chattisgarh was created because of "alleged" apathy shown by M.P towards development of the state. While I may be unaware of factual from a "data" perspective, don't think it has helped Chattisgarh in terms of taking a "leap" in developing the area. Similar example could be given about Jharkhand. When there is sincerity and will to achieve in the leadership, it can be done with or without having a separate statehood per se. In any case, this whole gimmick would end in Congress making certain that they don't lose their poll plank in whether in "splitted" Andhra or the whole one. TRS would make sure that his party remains at helm and enjoys ruling. People (including those who have been passionately striving for a statehood and gone to the extremes of committing suicide) would be buoyed for a while realizing later that, things remain the same. Win Win for all ... Hoping it doesn't mean I am insensitive beast, enjoy the show. I would give a rating of 2.5 because of poor script writing, predictable story line and bland acting.
Manish Jain
Splitting Andhra & creating Telangana is not Good. it'll set a wrong trend to make small states. It is wrong that anybody who wish to success in politics by way of ruling small states can go for fast & set right any wrong doing. Govt. should act tough & try to resolve the Issues due to which these type of Demands unearthed. Govt should also punish Guilty who is holding the Development in such areas like Telangana & Vidharbha.
Ravi Gupta
I believe Chattisgarh was created because of "alleged" apathy shown by M.P towards development of the state. While I may be unaware of factual from a "data" perspective, don't think it has helped Chattisgarh in terms of taking a "leap" in developing the area. Similar example could be given about Jharkhand. When there is sincerity and will to achieve in the leadership, it can be done with or without having a separate statehood per se. In any case, this whole gimmick would end in Congress making certain that they don't lose their poll plank in whether in "splitted" Andhra or the whole one. TRS would make sure that his party remains at helm and enjoys ruling. People (including those who have been passionately striving for a statehood and gone to the extremes of committing suicide) would be buoyed for a while realizing later that, things remain the same. Win Win for all ... Hoping it doesn't mean I am insensitive beast, enjoy the show. I would give a rating of 2.5 because of poor script writing, predictable story line and bland acting.
Raman Lal Raniga
INSAAN KEE ZINDAGI BHI
EKH BHAGWAAN KA PREM KEE KAHANI HAIH
HAMMEH SEEKHANA HOGA PREM SEH JEEHNNA
JEEOH AURRH JEEHNNEH DOH
NA KEE DHARAMMO KEH LAFEHDHEH MEH
MAAR KAAT VEEYARRTH ZINDAGI BEH RAHAMH KEE
SEEKHLOH INSAAN MONARCH BUTTERFLIES SEH
http://features.csmonitor.com/environmen t/2009/12/10/butterflies-versus-beetles/
TASVEER
MIRACLES OF MAKER
I AM OVERJOYED WITH THIS PICTURE
I AWE AT MONARCH BUTTERFLIES
I ADMIRE THE BUTTERFLIES THE STRENGTH THEY HAVE
THEIR INNER STRENGTH I REALIZE COMES FROM YOUNG AGE
WHEN THEY ARE WRIGGLERS CATERPILLARS
THROUGH THE MIRACLES OF MAKER
THEN THEY GO IN MEDITATIONAL SAMADHI
AND BECOME A NEW CREATURE THE AMAZING BUTTERFLIES
LOOK AT HOW MANY HUMAN MILES BUTTERFLIES FLIES
THIS IS NO JOKE A REALITY FOR IT LIVES A VERY CLEAN LIFE JOURNEY INDEED
NOT HURTING ANY OTHER CREATURES OR CREATIONS ANY MORE
THE TRUE BORN-AGAIN CATERPILLARS
INSAAN KEE ZINDAGI BHI
EKH BHAGWAAN KA PREM KEE KAHANI HAIH
HAMMEH SEEKHANA HOGA PREM SEH JEEHNNA
JEEOH AURRH JEEHNNEH DOH
NA KEE DHARAMMO KEH LAFEHDHEH MEH
MAAR KAAT VEEYARRTH ZINDAGI BEH RAHAMH KEE
SEEKHLOH INSAAN MONARCH BUTTERFLIES SEH
EKH BHAGWAAN KA PREM KEE KAHANI HAIH
HAMMEH SEEKHANA HOGA PREM SEH JEEHNNA
JEEOH AURRH JEEHNNEH DOH
NA KEE DHARAMMO KEH LAFEHDHEH MEH
MAAR KAAT VEEYARRTH ZINDAGI BEH RAHAMH KEE
SEEKHLOH INSAAN MONARCH BUTTERFLIES SEH
http://features.csmonitor.com/environmen t/2009/12/10/butterflies-versus-beetles/
TASVEER
MIRACLES OF MAKER
I AM OVERJOYED WITH THIS PICTURE
I AWE AT MONARCH BUTTERFLIES
I ADMIRE THE BUTTERFLIES THE STRENGTH THEY HAVE
THEIR INNER STRENGTH I REALIZE COMES FROM YOUNG AGE
WHEN THEY ARE WRIGGLERS CATERPILLARS
THROUGH THE MIRACLES OF MAKER
THEN THEY GO IN MEDITATIONAL SAMADHI
AND BECOME A NEW CREATURE THE AMAZING BUTTERFLIES
LOOK AT HOW MANY HUMAN MILES BUTTERFLIES FLIES
THIS IS NO JOKE A REALITY FOR IT LIVES A VERY CLEAN LIFE JOURNEY INDEED
NOT HURTING ANY OTHER CREATURES OR CREATIONS ANY MORE
THE TRUE BORN-AGAIN CATERPILLARS
INSAAN KEE ZINDAGI BHI
EKH BHAGWAAN KA PREM KEE KAHANI HAIH
HAMMEH SEEKHANA HOGA PREM SEH JEEHNNA
JEEOH AURRH JEEHNNEH DOH
NA KEE DHARAMMO KEH LAFEHDHEH MEH
MAAR KAAT VEEYARRTH ZINDAGI BEH RAHAMH KEE
SEEKHLOH INSAAN MONARCH BUTTERFLIES SEH
Siva Lex
All these political idiots dont know how to make the State better...so they are trying their best to brainwash all the illiterates in the country to do all these kinds of disruptive things.... The people should be ashamed of such a thing of breaking the state....
Bhompal Rathore
As per i think the telengana formation is certainly a negative point........
Two basic problems arise from this move. The first is the opportunism of the politicians from the other two regions -- Coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema. Already most MPs and 100 MLAs of these two regions have revolted. Undesirable elements will jump in to create more trouble. The Congress high command has to be wary of its own local leaders who could create mischief if it suits their interests.
Above all, K Rosaiah seems to be a weak chief minister looking to the high command for every single move and also passing the buck to Congress President Sonia Gandhi and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh
Secondly, there is bound to be a domino effect in other states. The demand for Vidarbha maharastra , Bundelkhand (Uttar Pradesh , Harit Pradesh (UP), Saurashtra (Gujarat) and Gorkhaland (West Bengal are already pending. People in these states may become emboldened if they think that the Centre would cave in if someone went on a fast or indulged in violence.
so govt. should take in mind before coming to any conclusions........
i think so that,what u say..............?
Two basic problems arise from this move. The first is the opportunism of the politicians from the other two regions -- Coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema. Already most MPs and 100 MLAs of these two regions have revolted. Undesirable elements will jump in to create more trouble. The Congress high command has to be wary of its own local leaders who could create mischief if it suits their interests.
Above all, K Rosaiah seems to be a weak chief minister looking to the high command for every single move and also passing the buck to Congress President Sonia Gandhi and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh
Secondly, there is bound to be a domino effect in other states. The demand for Vidarbha maharastra , Bundelkhand (Uttar Pradesh , Harit Pradesh (UP), Saurashtra (Gujarat) and Gorkhaland (West Bengal are already pending. People in these states may become emboldened if they think that the Centre would cave in if someone went on a fast or indulged in violence.
so govt. should take in mind before coming to any conclusions........
i think so that,what u say..............?
Prasad Patkar
I dont understan what the fuss is all about, they wanted a telangana state, Our congress govt has got no brains, they couldhave avoided this crisis, by naming andhra pradesh as telangana....... so easy it was..... Idiots.....
Sekhar Nallani
Megha , Do not understand why you feel it is not in the country's interest.
would it be in the country;s interest if one region depletes the resources of the other region , deprives them of their rightful opportunities, conveniently forgets the 'gentleman;s agreements and otherwse makes them irrelevent in their own place?
Please justify your answer by giving some concrete reasons.if possible.
would it be in the country;s interest if one region depletes the resources of the other region , deprives them of their rightful opportunities, conveniently forgets the 'gentleman;s agreements and otherwse makes them irrelevent in their own place?
Please justify your answer by giving some concrete reasons.if possible.
Sekhar Nallani
Telangana Issue has been going on for over 50 years.The discrimation and apathy towards Telangana was total and complete under the united andhra rule.
The agitation for separate Telangana, as witnessed by the whole country was spontaneous and real.It is not because of KCR that telangana was declared.. remember what happened when KCR broke the fast with in 2 days..
Coming to the resignation drama by Andhra and Rayalaseema, birds of a feather, it is pure political gimmick. Why are they inssiting on staying together when Telangana people have been fighting to part ways for so long time. It is any body's guess.
Why no one in telangana is protesting and only in Andhra we see these orchestrated actions.
The agitation for separate Telangana, as witnessed by the whole country was spontaneous and real.It is not because of KCR that telangana was declared.. remember what happened when KCR broke the fast with in 2 days..
Coming to the resignation drama by Andhra and Rayalaseema, birds of a feather, it is pure political gimmick. Why are they inssiting on staying together when Telangana people have been fighting to part ways for so long time. It is any body's guess.
Why no one in telangana is protesting and only in Andhra we see these orchestrated actions.
Rau Dev
KCR has become my guiding light and source of inspiration.
I am now inspired to go on a FAST TO BURP for a separate..... WASHROOM!!!!
I am now inspired to go on a FAST TO BURP for a separate..... WASHROOM!!!!
Mohan Muralidhar N..
for me i am not satisfy with the center decision for another state of Telengana only for the reason that some one went for a fast.But i could not understand that except this issue we have other separate state issue like GorkhaLand which is very old demand.I could not think how center made its decision .Its not satisfied me only for a reason someone going for fast & if something happen to him may be there willbe a law & order problem.but this is not the right decision for this case.Also is center give this decision on pressure?
If like this has happened then i am sorry to say that our center is not a good governing body for our nation.The governing body must know that citizen are for a state or nation not state or nation is for a citizen.This is very important for ruling member & must mind it.
At last i want to say why people want a different statehood.
Can the demand for different statehood will solve problem of there daily life?
Or they want for their different culture or language?
If the peoples choice for another statehood for language then its OK.But for other case i don't think it is a good demand.
At last i want to say if we stay together then we will be powerful.Else GOD knows what will happen to the country.
Why don't People admit they don't believe in unity who's demand are not up to mark?
If like this has happened then i am sorry to say that our center is not a good governing body for our nation.The governing body must know that citizen are for a state or nation not state or nation is for a citizen.This is very important for ruling member & must mind it.
At last i want to say why people want a different statehood.
Can the demand for different statehood will solve problem of there daily life?
Or they want for their different culture or language?
If the peoples choice for another statehood for language then its OK.But for other case i don't think it is a good demand.
At last i want to say if we stay together then we will be powerful.Else GOD knows what will happen to the country.
Why don't People admit they don't believe in unity who's demand are not up to mark?
Sekhar Nallani Mohan,
I think you are confused,
Telangana is in India and is not going anywhere jsut want to get separated from oppressive Andhra rulers to rotect their rights which is a fuindamental right. It took 50 years and many lives to get here. Please get your facts right
I think you are confused,
Telangana is in India and is not going anywhere jsut want to get separated from oppressive Andhra rulers to rotect their rights which is a fuindamental right. It took 50 years and many lives to get here. Please get your facts right
Gilberto Defreitas
It may sound strange but it is best that both states be governed from Hyderabad with each state having their own govenor, Chief Minister etc,etc. What do you think? Gilliana Oz
Pradeep Gupta
It is better to have small states fr overall development of the country. in a small state funds can be easily allocated to the most neededpart of the state for development. in a big state the govt. can't reac every part of the state and some portion remain unwanted and under developed. that creats dissatisfaction and various other negative facts of democracy.
Shrinivasa Kamath
Another state for what? Will those, believing in violence as seen now, deliver goods for the poor who are the worst affected in whichever state they are? If backwardness is the reason, what prevented them to act all these days? Why TRS almost lost the recent assembly elections?
Sekhar Nallani Mr.kamath,
TRS lsot he last elections because of KCR. People did not like his attitude and pranks.Please remember that all the parties fought the elections on Telangana slogan, saying that only they are capable o getting the separate Telangana.
TRS lsot he last elections because of KCR. People did not like his attitude and pranks.Please remember that all the parties fought the elections on Telangana slogan, saying that only they are capable o getting the separate Telangana.
Sai Kishore we want Telengana because it is the ambition of this people since our independence. In the 1st SRC it is clearly mentioned that Telengana should not be clubbed with Andhra. If u want more information about this go through the videos in the link http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-41398820725610 17394#.
Ajay Theegala
I ask every one who are against seperate states one question ...Is it good to have one keeper for a herd of 100 sheeps. or two one for 50 sheeps ....in which case the keeper can take good care.....dont reply me that each sheep need a keeper we should also take care of resources in our hand to take care of keepers
Prasad Patkar Baseless point. Ur theory will look good on paper and not in reality. tomorow one from the 50 sheeps will come and will say that i will take care of 25 sheeps..... and so on the story will contiune....... So my freind pls give a thaught to this.
Sabu Joseph
It is ridiculous people like to Rao using Gandhiji’s way to blackmail and exploit the power. The decision to carve out a separate state of Telangana, which will take the total number of states in the Union to 29. Jharkhand split from Bihar to become the 28th state while Uttarakhand split from UP and Chattisgarh was created in the same year. Telangan region comprises Hyderabad, Adilabad, Nizamabad, Karimnagar, Medak, Warangal, Rangareddy, Nalgonda, Khammam and Mahbubnagar.
People of north-coastal Andhra - which consists of Srikakulam, Vizianagaram and Visakhapatnam districts – are demanding that the three districts be formed into a separate state in the event of bifurcating AP. The Centre's decision may fuel demands for separate "Andhra", separate "Rayalaseema" and even a separate "north-coastal Andhra". United India’s soul is burning. Telangana region now accounts for 119 of the 294 seats in the Assembly and 17 of the 42 Lok Sabha members. It’s only for mere political greed. I don't feel they have anything significant to contribute.
People of north-coastal Andhra - which consists of Srikakulam, Vizianagaram and Visakhapatnam districts – are demanding that the three districts be formed into a separate state in the event of bifurcating AP. The Centre's decision may fuel demands for separate "Andhra", separate "Rayalaseema" and even a separate "north-coastal Andhra". United India’s soul is burning. Telangana region now accounts for 119 of the 294 seats in the Assembly and 17 of the 42 Lok Sabha members. It’s only for mere political greed. I don't feel they have anything significant to contribute.
Sekhar Nallani Nobody is demanding for separate state other than Telangana for so many years.These are some issues that greedy politicians rake up to thwart the telangana statehood progress. Dont fall for these argments .Pelase read about Telangana before jumping to conclusions.
Abhishek Kumar
sometimes creating a ne state is correct, though it should be taken care of the objective of the creation must be the development of the unprivileged section..
for bigger states it's difficult to maintain and provide basic amenities to the remote areas. But the purpose of splitting should not be diluted with politics as it normally happens...
for bigger states it's difficult to maintain and provide basic amenities to the remote areas. But the purpose of splitting should not be diluted with politics as it normally happens...
Sekhar Nallani Just my 2 cents to put things in perspective.The state of AP as formed by merging two regions and since then one region is trying to get out of the unholy alliance as it is at the receiveing end all the time. Even after 50 years the cultural diversity is still as it was. There is no assimilation of cultures or way of life , people do not even marry between regions, the creaton of Telangana is not splitting AP it is restoring the balnace that was disrupted by the merger.
Rajinder Katoch
Splitting any big state is right. Because sometimes under the tall trees, others less important do not get opportunity to grow. There is language differenence in Andhra in Telangana, coastal andhra and railseema, I don't know whether my spellings are correct.
Assam was split into seven states, Punjab was split into three states, Uttarakhand was carved out of UP and furhter Harit Pradesh should also be given. This way power balance will be equal. Otherwise, states like Bihar, UP, Rajasthan will always have stronger say than states who are honestly helping country to grow may be smaller in size.
Assam was split into seven states, Punjab was split into three states, Uttarakhand was carved out of UP and furhter Harit Pradesh should also be given. This way power balance will be equal. Otherwise, states like Bihar, UP, Rajasthan will always have stronger say than states who are honestly helping country to grow may be smaller in size.
Prasanna S
Indians known for Unity in diversty. But these days people showing their unity to make themselves diverse.
Gilberto Defreitas
Megha Talwar. I will agree with you. But one can only expect this from a Congress government that refuse to accept responsibility and find the easiest route to escape the problem by conceding to the demands to that blackmailer, C Rao. As you will note that whether it is the Gujrat communal riots or the bombing of Parliament or the Lalegoan bombings or the Chinese incursions or 26/11, the Congress led UPA government just prefers to sit on its backside and wait till such time they are out of office and another government comes into power and the responsibility automatically is passed on. Perhaps to be a politician is to enjoy gratification on the way, access the huge superannuation that is meted out to them , to enjoy a free life with all the free facilities and then hand over the chair to their son/daughter. The only good thing that really comes out of this seperation is that both states can be administrated better. United we stand, divided we fall. We are witnessing the slow disintegration of India caused by selfish, time serving politicians that not only serve their own agenda but also that of the enemy.
When Gandhi took on fasting it was for the national interest. Now people like CRao is using this means as the ultimate blackmail. This is a very sad day for India., and wonders what the Chinese have already made known that when India disintegrates into small seperate nations, it will then be easier to take over.
When Gandhi took on fasting it was for the national interest. Now people like CRao is using this means as the ultimate blackmail. This is a very sad day for India., and wonders what the Chinese have already made known that when India disintegrates into small seperate nations, it will then be easier to take over.
Santosh Bhujbal
This is very sad moment.
Now there are 8 more such demands for states.
Now all of them and more such demands will also come forward.
What will we achieve in such state splitting?
Now there are 8 more such demands for states.
Now all of them and more such demands will also come forward.
What will we achieve in such state splitting?
Madhav Kadam
iam very happy to read and listen the above news. it is the need of time to be seperated from each other, india is known as a country of unity in diversity. now we are in 20th centyry and if we have become developed nation, it is the need of time and do your best which you have not done earlier.
many people says that, it will become the matter of crisis, i don`t agree with this. it was the time when we were under british imperialism,that time we have fought many riots against virtual states in our country. It will not be wrong if our government will decide to give freedom of seperation, the responsibility will rise on the shoulders of new states and each one stand very firm to do their best, this freedom will teach the new born states, how to live,live and lead life successfully,i will personally thanks to our government if it will give freedom not only telangana, gorkhaland,and vrdharbha,but all of them who were interested to be free and fight for life on their on own risks.
many people says that, it will become the matter of crisis, i don`t agree with this. it was the time when we were under british imperialism,that time we have fought many riots against virtual states in our country. It will not be wrong if our government will decide to give freedom of seperation, the responsibility will rise on the shoulders of new states and each one stand very firm to do their best, this freedom will teach the new born states, how to live,live and lead life successfully,i will personally thanks to our government if it will give freedom not only telangana, gorkhaland,and vrdharbha,but all of them who were interested to be free and fight for life on their on own risks.
Keizer Soze no way...only the political brass and bureaucracy will gain from this, the aam admi will suffer regardless. Division will only hamper and slow down any process of development slow as it is in rural India. You cant divide Telangana from Andhra, they cant do without eachother. I am from Telangana, even if it is divided, no way they will get Hyderabad. without Hyd, Telangana is useless. If people from same language can't get along, how united is the country. F*** BJP, TDP, TRS and Congress for giving into this 'chutiya', they should have let KCR die, no body cares about him. He is so useless that he didnt even bother contest in recent Hyd municipal elections, he is a suicidal idiot and the Govt. just gave into him. Who cares if a few students take to the streets, they dont pay any taxes, they have little say in this matter. They too are useless.
Vijay Bhanu
Everyone should know the history of Telangana before u come to some conclusions.Telanganites are neglected,ignored and exploited in many ways.Politicians who has given support for telangana state are now resigning their posts to stop formation of telangana state hood. This is really bcoz still they are thirsty to exploit telanganites.Now its the time for the telanganites stay unite .
Navin Bhansali Mr. Army Man why you always speak rubish void of any facts and practical aspects. You are a person who only see the negativity of the things. Know the facts, understand, analyse and then come to a conclusion. You are a sick person, frustrated and I pity on you. Really, you need a break and I can understand all these tensions and torments that you undergo in army training make you such a fustrated soul. I will pray for you Mr. Army man. May God be with you.
Laxmi Nanda When they wanted to form United Andhra Pradesh they want all the resources belonging to Telangana. Now when wanted to Separate they want only part of the state to divide as they developed that part ?
and leave the rest of the undeveloped as it is ?
as the all of them say it still is intergral part of india right so there should not be any worries.
When the people didn't wanted to have a united andhra pradesh before its formation they did it against the will of Telangana people. Now everybody talks when people are carving for a separation from past 5 decades.
Dont people of telangana have any right to decide on what they want ?
Should not they ask for what they want?
when they ask for their rights all they will be given a shoot at sight order.
Dont you think too much of suppressions will worsen the situation rather than getting it any better?
and leave the rest of the undeveloped as it is ?
as the all of them say it still is intergral part of india right so there should not be any worries.
When the people didn't wanted to have a united andhra pradesh before its formation they did it against the will of Telangana people. Now everybody talks when people are carving for a separation from past 5 decades.
Dont people of telangana have any right to decide on what they want ?
Should not they ask for what they want?
when they ask for their rights all they will be given a shoot at sight order.
Dont you think too much of suppressions will worsen the situation rather than getting it any better?
Keizer Soze well for thousands of years the Indian subcontinent included Pakistan, all of Kashmir and many other regions but history changes, Pakistan is separate, many parts of Kashmir belong to Pak and China. Things change, more than 1/2 the population of the country has problems with the basics in life, where is your bleeding heart for them. The politicians already divide and rule now you want more division. I can gurantee you even if Telangana is formed they wont get HYD. Even if they do get HYD, no body will invest. HYD is crucial place on the Indian map, strategically the most important because Indian nuclear and tactical missiles are built over there, the reason for this is a lot of local talent, local companies all across Andhra Pradesh. So, no way they will let a state to be formed. The Central Govt. may approve it but the local politics wont allow for this to happen. Shame on you for wanting a separate state.
Dilip Krishnan
In India States were organised on linguistic lines. Later states like Bihar, UP and MP were split though the people speak the same language (dialects may vary). But there was consensus for this and it was done in a peaceful manner by and large since these states were large with a huge population. But it makes no sense to divide Andhra Pradesh. This would not be in the interest of either Telangana, Rayalseema or the Coastal Areas. Hence all political parties , national and regional must come together to prevent this from happening.
Keizer Soze Laxmi Ji this is indeed sad but this is the same story in Bihar, UP, Jharkhand, Orissa, Bengal and many other places including in Andhra, Telangana is no exception to it. these are all problems that the country in general faces, when a Telangana person can become PM why not someone from Telangana strong enough to become CM, if he/she becomes CM they can bring development to Telangana. CMs are anyways regional in their behaviour. I am from Telangana so dont bother showing me these videos and anyone who says developement hasnt come to Telangana is flatly lying. there has been lots of development and it will slowly continue. Statehood will only slow it down.
Laxmi Nanda @Keizer Soze If you have time please look at this document and let us know whether we were right.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-41398820725610 17394&hl=en#
If you still think that now also we want united andhra pradesh then we cant help it.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-41398820725610 17394&hl=en#
If you still think that now also we want united andhra pradesh then we cant help it.
King Khan Keizer bhai, you are right in saying that united we stand. But, if telangana people are genuinely craving for a separate, I think it'd be in the interest of all to separate amicably rather than indulge in a widespread commotion. I'm quite sure that separation won't do any good to either regions and peoples if not any bad. And, as you said there are a lot of sensitive issues involved like the status of hyderabad etc. Lets hope for the best!!!
Keizer Soze Its simple Khan sahab, united we stand, divided we fall, Telangana cant do without the rest of Andhra and is useless wihtout HYD. Hyderabad wont be a part of Telangana as they hope it to be, they can have separate state but no HYD. Without HYD no use. HYD will become union territory but thats as far as it goes. But they wont let seprate state to be formed in the first place because i know for a fact that there are more people who want a united Andhra Pradesh than people that want a separate Telangana. Just because some 'chutiya' comes along and says 'fast unto death' the people of Andhra wont give in. A large crowd of jobless students, party workers is hardly representative of democracy. we all know how parties work, they pay people to disrupt and destroy state property and hold the city hostage till someone succumbs to pressure. Congress should have let the idiot die coz he comes from the most uselss breed of politician that needs to be suicidal to get any attention.
King Khan I can understand your feelings for United Andhra and it is obvious for a person hailing from the Andhra region to feel so. Even, I'm from the Andhra region and used to think so before knowing the issues of Telangana people. It can be stated without any doubt that it's been neglected for a long time. I'm not saying that KCR is going to do any good or some x for that matter. Its just that the Telangana people have every right to decide their future be it for the best or the worst. Atleast, they won't have anyone to blame for any future anarchy.
Rajeev Reddy
Central govt nods head towards TRS now to get KCR back from hell... But the resignation of seema, andhra MLAs..., and the new...students' rally against separate TELANGANA dominates the main issue and it'll again be postponed....... What an intelligent govt....ha..ha:-) atleast in this issue i hope govt will behave good... And SamaykyaAndhra is needed for us now...... Breakup:( is not the correct solution.....!!
Sekhar Nallani Rajeev, Why it is not a good idea or let me rephrase is to whom it is not a good idea.Look who ies revolting after the declaration of Telangana state process, the politicians and the goons of Rayalaseema and Andhra, no body is running from pillar to post against Telangana from Telangana regon.
Why are only coastal and the Andhra leaders are agitating that has been the crux of Telngana agitation. The andhra and Rayalaseema doesnt want to let go the goodies from Telangana.
Everything will be ok once Telangana is formed.
Why are only coastal and the Andhra leaders are agitating that has been the crux of Telngana agitation. The andhra and Rayalaseema doesnt want to let go the goodies from Telangana.
Everything will be ok once Telangana is formed.
Sai Kishore Samakya andhra why? Just to eat out all the resources from this region. From past 50 years andhra politicians are doing this still what you want.
You are like mosquitoes sucking blood from our people.
You are like mosquitoes sucking blood from our people.
King Khan
There are too many vested interests in this whole episode. Telangana leaders who are more of a failure saw this as an opportunity to attain certain posts which they were never capable of attaining given their political wisdom and background. On the other hand many Andhra people have stakes in Telangana and Hyderabad in particular that they can't easily let go. Its a messy and tricky situation which is impossible to sort out without much chaos and disappointments of either parties. If Telangana indeed shapes up I hope its done long impending justice rather than just turning into an object of exploitation by a brand new caravan of corrupt politicians and leaders which is most likely. I don't think either United Andhra or bifurcated Andhra is a solution to this unrest. Our leaders leave no stone unturned to plunder the masses whether it is United Andhra or the two states (i hope not more than two) yet to form.
Navin Bhansali I agree with you on the situation regarding Jharkand. It is a sick state where governance is not at all good. Replace the corrupt politicians and you will see Jharkhand also will prosper. Moreover, Jharkhand has taken most of the resources from Bihar and still if corrupted minds rule the state, We can go no where. If you see Bihar, Chatishgarh and Uthrakhand it has prospered a lot after division and even UP is doing good. So, I am not saying that keep on dividing states into smaller number but the thing is when you neglect the areas or regions of a state, it is very likely that people of that area will revolt. Either try to develop those area or make it a separate state. That way it will receive grants and funds from the centre and hence will prosper and if a state prosper it is very likely that India will prosper. I am against the unneccesary divison based on religious beliefs but the issue og Telengana is more than that. It is a neglected state and it needs to separate. People at centre are not fools, they are educated and sensible. They know very well what to do and not to do. That is why Manmohan is a PM and not people like you who just keep on talking nonsense without seeing into the reasons. You can not make a rocket until you know the principle that governs its creation. So, my dear so called intelligent fellas, check the facts and then comment
Keizer Soze yeah right Navin, running your mouth again, the smaller the state doesnt mean jack if the politicians dont do anything. Look at Jharkhand, there has been no progress on the ground ever since the state was formed. And with 'chutiya' politicians like Madhu Koda and KCR, the separate state has no hope and will end up being worse than before. you obviously have no idea about Andhra pradesh, just stick to watching TV. If you think a suicidal a**hole like KCR will do anything even after separation, well its a pipe dream, he just like all the other A**holes, c'mon man he had to threaten to die to get any attention, he is so desperate for power that he had to go on suicidal mode to get anything done. To me he is no different than a terrorist.
King Khan Lady, what a stupid comparison? Here we are not giving telangana to anybody. It'll still remain an integral part of India. Don't just say something because you have to...
Navin Bhansali Well, Pakistan is not a part of India... Andhra and Telengana are the states of India and I dont think dividing into states is a wrong idea. The smaller the state, the better it is look after. Moreover, if you see Andhra, the coastal areas, other than Hyderabad ofcourse, are better developed and the Telengana part is neglected since it got merged in 1956.
Rishi Chand Thota
Seems like everybody here is looking for a united India. But if we see when I was in my 10th Standard there were 25 states in India, but now there are 28 states. And nearly decision for new 9 states in pending in which Telangana is a part.
Before making any statement people have to analyze the prevailing solution. The leaders who had resigned to their MLA's and MP's post are mainly from Andhra and Rayalseema naturally are from the parties who had favoured Separate statehood for Telangana, but soon the announcement came these people have resigned. These people were silent when KCR was on fast,. none othem had spoken about United Andhra Pradesh. And these people are ready for Separate Telangana without Hyderabad. The only reason why a state is divided is only for political reasons and to my knowledge there are very small number of politicians who are looking for development of the country. I am unable to see any good leader after Atal Bihari Vajpayeeji and ManMohan Singh who always had a vision to develop India.
And coming to state politics what ever is happening is only because of politics and the students are being made scape goats in this entire issue. If such situations are to be stopped growth should be equal in all the ares of the state.
And it would be nice if any one show one other developed place in Telangana other than Hyderabad which is a little bit developed.
Nothing but if we go to Andhra they have Vijaywada, Vizag and Guntur which have all the facilites to become capitals at any given day. And all these three regions are from Andhra and none from Rayalseema which is seeing some development after YSR became the CM. People can say that tirupati is from Rayalseema and what ever development is there in Tirupati is only because of Lord Venkateswara but not because of any political party.
Separate Statehood may not be solution for any problem. Atleast by this instance all the political leaders should think of development of the entire states or country but not the region,religion or cast to which they belong.
My comments here may be not quite clear, but the only feeling I have is we need politicians who care for Development of INDIA.
Before making any statement people have to analyze the prevailing solution. The leaders who had resigned to their MLA's and MP's post are mainly from Andhra and Rayalseema naturally are from the parties who had favoured Separate statehood for Telangana, but soon the announcement came these people have resigned. These people were silent when KCR was on fast,. none othem had spoken about United Andhra Pradesh. And these people are ready for Separate Telangana without Hyderabad. The only reason why a state is divided is only for political reasons and to my knowledge there are very small number of politicians who are looking for development of the country. I am unable to see any good leader after Atal Bihari Vajpayeeji and ManMohan Singh who always had a vision to develop India.
And coming to state politics what ever is happening is only because of politics and the students are being made scape goats in this entire issue. If such situations are to be stopped growth should be equal in all the ares of the state.
And it would be nice if any one show one other developed place in Telangana other than Hyderabad which is a little bit developed.
Nothing but if we go to Andhra they have Vijaywada, Vizag and Guntur which have all the facilites to become capitals at any given day. And all these three regions are from Andhra and none from Rayalseema which is seeing some development after YSR became the CM. People can say that tirupati is from Rayalseema and what ever development is there in Tirupati is only because of Lord Venkateswara but not because of any political party.
Separate Statehood may not be solution for any problem. Atleast by this instance all the political leaders should think of development of the entire states or country but not the region,religion or cast to which they belong.
My comments here may be not quite clear, but the only feeling I have is we need politicians who care for Development of INDIA.
King Khan I agree to some extent about what you are saying. Lemme just add a few to your points. If you feel that Tirupati is what it is because of Lord Venkateshwara then you also have to admit that Vijayawada is because of Durga, Vizag is because of the harbor and steel plant, Guntur is because of tobacco, cotton, chili markets etc.
There's no point in trying to justify anything. The thing that matters is the equal development that hasn't happened. This issue should have been resolved long ago so that these complaints don't arise in the first place. Now that they have its better to respect the majority opinion whatever it might be. And, I think the best way is to carry out a referendum in Telangana regarding its future. Fate of Telangana should be decided by the people of the region rather than the corrupt and disoriented politicians. And, its better for the people of Andhra to concede Telangana if the later wishes for a separate state.
There's no point in trying to justify anything. The thing that matters is the equal development that hasn't happened. This issue should have been resolved long ago so that these complaints don't arise in the first place. Now that they have its better to respect the majority opinion whatever it might be. And, I think the best way is to carry out a referendum in Telangana regarding its future. Fate of Telangana should be decided by the people of the region rather than the corrupt and disoriented politicians. And, its better for the people of Andhra to concede Telangana if the later wishes for a separate state.
Kris Saini
WHERE WE ARE GOING TO DRAW A LINE? SO EVERY TIME SOME STUPID NETA GO ON A HUNGER STRIKE WE ARE GOING TO SPLIT THE COUNTRY UNTILL INDIA BECOMES A GROUP OF SMALL BITE SIZE MUNICIPILITIES. ARE WE GOING TO UNDO ALL THE EFFORTS AND SCRIFICE OF SARDAR PATEL?PUT LOT OF FOR.This is sad day indeed.
Sekhar Nallani Kris,
Telangana was not given for KCR's fast.The fast is the culmination of all the efforts and sufering of aTelangana people over 50 years.Deprived of opportunities that are rightfully theirs and discrimination in every area has lead to thie spontaneous mass upheaval. It went beyond KCR's grip after he gave up 2 days into his agitaion and was rather forced to continue by popular demand.
When you do not experience the aboce mentione problems you fail to unerstand the depth of pain that people of Telangana went through..
Telangana was not given for KCR's fast.The fast is the culmination of all the efforts and sufering of aTelangana people over 50 years.Deprived of opportunities that are rightfully theirs and discrimination in every area has lead to thie spontaneous mass upheaval. It went beyond KCR's grip after he gave up 2 days into his agitaion and was rather forced to continue by popular demand.
When you do not experience the aboce mentione problems you fail to unerstand the depth of pain that people of Telangana went through..
Laxmi Nanda So you see 11 days of hunger strike but not the struggle of more than 40% people of andhra pradesh for more than 5 Decades?????????
Rishi Chand Thota Indian tradition is to respect elders, if you know some one is wrong it should be said in a polite manner.
Shekar Kamaraju
As they say History repeats, divide and rule has come in again, but this time with a dose of rowdyism. KCR a well known drunkard with his blackmail tactics and hooliganism has got what he wants. Now his family will rule and plunder the region for generations. We have seen formation of Pakistan for a selfish motive of Jinnah and now we are seeing Telangana for KCR's political greed. In future we will see many others coming up with arm twisting tactics and making India vulnerable for external elements, remember we are surrounded with unstable nations.
Rishi Chand Thota Can you name a leader who is not a drunkard, who is not into bribery. recently the only name I heard of such a leader in AP is only late PJR. I am a little bit weak in politics. Waiting for the status of JP of loksatta.
Prasad Patkar
Dividing a state is not going to help the new state to prosper, as we have seen about chatisgarh and jharkhand. Rather solving the problem, congrss govt has created a problem. now there will be fight between people of Andrapradesh and teengana, the new cold war has stared between Andrapardesh and telegana. Congress to achevie sucess is adapting the same rule, which decades ago Britishers has used. Divide and Rule.
Rishi Chand Thota It is not only congress who had supported it, this is crime of each and every political party in India.
Prasad Patkar
Dividing a state is not going to help the new state to prosper, as we have seen about chatisgarh and jharkhand. Rather solving the problem, congrss govt has created a problem. now there will be fight between people of Andrapradesh and teengana, the new cold war has stared between Andrapardesh and telegana. Congress to achevie sucess is adapting the same rule, which decades ago Britishers has used. Divide and Rule.
Shubhendu Ghosh
Now you all can clearly see te impact as more parties as going on agitation asking for the statehood. We all talk about INDIA , but definitely people asking for such thing are least bothered about it. One state cannot be developed unless there is a will to do so. For that you don't need a seperate state.
Rishi Chand Thota You are right, India could have been developed if there are no states in it. but earlier for easy ruling they had divided it on language basis. Earlier peole used to think for development of India, but they care only about there personal accounts balance, so more number of states, more number of CM's and ministers. Every body into bribery so all of them will earn equally and all indians will be ata a equal status one day.
Aparna Jorapur
Black mail works and fasting helps....very soon we will have thin politicians and every city as a state. This is wrong...or should we start checking the pre-independence map
Laxmi Nanda So you see 11 days of hunger strike but not the struggle of more than 40% people of andhra pradesh for more than 5 Decades?????????
Ikram Siddiqui
Does anyone know the history. its bad that center bow in front of blackmail but question of telangana as an state or be in vishal andhra was from the root of our independence or before that The Telangana region was mentioned in the Maha bharat as telinga Kingdom. India become independent in 1947 When India became independent, the Telugu-speaking people were distributed in about 22 districts; 9 of them in the Telangana region of Nizam's Dominions (Hyderabad State)n December 1953, Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru appointed the States Reorganization Commission to prepare for the creation of states on linguistic linesThe States Reorganization Commission (SRC) was not in favour of merging the Telangana region with the then Andhra state. Para 382 of States Reorganization Commission Report (SRC) said "..opinion in Andhra is overwhelmingly in favour of the larger unit, public opinion in Telangana has still to crystallize itselfThe concerns of Telanganas were manifold . The region had a less developed economy than Andhra, but with a larger revenue base (mostly because it taxed rather than prohibited alcoholic beverages), which Telanganas feared might be diverted for use in Andhra. They also feared that planned dam projects on the Krishna and Godavari rivers would not benefit Telangana proportionately even though Telanganas controlled the headwaters of the rivers. Telanganas feared too that the people of Andhra would have the advantage in jobs, particularly in government and education. Para 386 of States Reorganization Commission Report (SRC) said "After taking all these factors into consideration we have come to the conclusions that it will be in the interests of Andhra as well as Telangana area is to constitute into a separate State, which may be known as the Hyderabad State with provision for its unification with Andhra after the general elections likely to be held in or about 1961 if by a two thirds majority the legislature of the residency Hyderabad State expresses itself in favor of such unification. Telangana people had a number of complaints about how the agreements and guarantees were implemented. Discontent with the 1956 Gentleman's agreement intensified in January 1969 when the guarantees that had been agreed on were supposed to lapse. Student agitation for the continuation of the agreement began at Osmania University in Hyderabad and spread to other parts of the region. Government employees and opposition members of the state legislative assembly swiftly threatened "direct action" in support of the students. This movement, also known as Telangana movement, led to widespread violence and deaths of hundreds of people and students of this Telangana region. Approximately 360 students gave their lives in this movement. I dont know whether this will be a better state or not after sepration but pls dont blame the people and plz comment on me too
Sumit Sarkar @Laxmi Nanda
It has always been like this everywhere. Money always goes in the politician's pockets and it will be the same even if Telangana is formed. Please don't divide Indian and her people anymore.
It has always been like this everywhere. Money always goes in the politician's pockets and it will be the same even if Telangana is formed. Please don't divide Indian and her people anymore.
Shridhar Bairi The answer lies in your question itself.
Why are you fighting for separation when the actual problem is development?
Do you really think after separation these same so called leaders will let the region develop. The fact of matter is it not that the region cannot be developed without separation. But these people do not want to do it because of their political motives. Whatever funds are allocated go into the pocket of the leaders and they exploit the separation tactic in elections. This a perfect situation for them and you are falling for it.
As far as the people supporting separation can be noticed from the fact that TRS was swept away in the polls.
Why are you fighting for separation when the actual problem is development?
Do you really think after separation these same so called leaders will let the region develop. The fact of matter is it not that the region cannot be developed without separation. But these people do not want to do it because of their political motives. Whatever funds are allocated go into the pocket of the leaders and they exploit the separation tactic in elections. This a perfect situation for them and you are falling for it.
As far as the people supporting separation can be noticed from the fact that TRS was swept away in the polls.
Laxmi Nanda Sridhar Bairi.
We are trying to ask so peacefull from 1969 that we want a separate state. dont people have a voice. Why everyone is looking at the political parties.
We are not trying to make enemies here.
So when you talk about Hyderabad development how much developed do you think it is ? after 50 years of formation people dont get drinking water what should we say? Do you really have any idea about the Lands that are sold out around Hyderabad it in Lakhs of acres?
Where did the money go. for Roads in Andhra?
How many people around Hyderabad are facing problem due to Grabbing of Lands by the government. You cannot comment on Hyderabad as it it developed.
There is a value that every politician has to pay for injustice to telangana.
We are trying to ask so peacefull from 1969 that we want a separate state. dont people have a voice. Why everyone is looking at the political parties.
We are not trying to make enemies here.
So when you talk about Hyderabad development how much developed do you think it is ? after 50 years of formation people dont get drinking water what should we say? Do you really have any idea about the Lands that are sold out around Hyderabad it in Lakhs of acres?
Where did the money go. for Roads in Andhra?
How many people around Hyderabad are facing problem due to Grabbing of Lands by the government. You cannot comment on Hyderabad as it it developed.
There is a value that every politician has to pay for injustice to telangana.
Rishi Chand Thota Mr. Sridhar Bairi, please name which is another region which is as developed as vijaywada, guntur, Vizag in telnagana region. What are the water projects that are supporting agriculture in telangana, then I will accept your comments. One thing is for sure none of the politician in AP is working for the people and they are not letting Even Rosiah do that by creating political instability.
Shridhar Bairi Everyone is talking about the history and that it was separate state. But what has happened in the 50+ yrs after merging that you want a separate state
We have had chief ministers and Prime minister as well from the region. Hyd is what it today just because it was made the capital of Andhra.
Do you really think KCR is really fighting for the people. Grow up he is just trying to save his political career. And the people of Telangana are the ones who rejected him.
What are you going to achieve by separate state that you cannot do with a united one. All you are going to do is escalate the tensions and make more enemies.
We have had chief ministers and Prime minister as well from the region. Hyd is what it today just because it was made the capital of Andhra.
Do you really think KCR is really fighting for the people. Grow up he is just trying to save his political career. And the people of Telangana are the ones who rejected him.
What are you going to achieve by separate state that you cannot do with a united one. All you are going to do is escalate the tensions and make more enemies.
Sunita H
How it will be good if states are divided. They are not dividing state they are dividing people hence India too. I would rather let that KCR die rather than letting united india die. These kind of people are not worth living.
Laxmi Nanda people of one part want it to be divided so why dont they ?
When they formed it people of Telangana didnot want United andhra pradesh. They forcibly did it. now we are fighting for the separation.
When they formed it people of Telangana didnot want United andhra pradesh. They forcibly did it. now we are fighting for the separation.
Navin Bhansali
The way it was done is really sad.... but looking into the reasons why telengana should be a separate state... I am sure it will benefit the state and the country as a whole. Even Bihar, UP and MP was divided but such violence and fasting didn't occur. And I dont feel that having n number of states is bad. Infact a small state can be progressed better than a normal large state which has so many problems that it cannot or sometimes don't want to look after the development of certain areas. This is what is happening to Telengana and so I think creating a new state is no harm if by this it can prosper and develop by getting financial help from centre as every states in India get. But if only prosperity for the region is a concern, I assume, creation of a new state is no harm. Seeing this, some elements may try to blackmail the govt. in division of more states just because of religious or cultural bias and this should not happen. We must use brains and do things that may help in prosperity of a country but not that divide our motherland. I think people at the centre are intelligent enough not to get carried away by such practices ad keep on dividing regions for no useful and unworthy reasons.
Navin Bhansali Mr Vashi you why you talk all nonsense. I dont know whic school you really attend where you are taught just one thing.... make comments and not see the real situation. And in one of your comments you said about "Where are the taxes going to come from if the area is not economically advanced?" Are you insane or may be your school never give lessons on taxes. The tax is given to centre and not state. The state only get revenues from goods they produce and manufacture baring some products like tea, petrol etc. So, teach yourself some lessons and then comment. I am only looking at why Telengana should be a seperate state and I have justified myself in this blog many times. If you want go through entire blog and the documents posted by Miss Laxmi Nanda and you will know the real situation. Comment only when you know the facts. And if I am using the words like feel, think and assume that suggests that I am giving my opinion and not forcing it. You have different opinion and I have different. Your thinking and my thinking are very different but I am not an arrogant prick like you. I think being kind and modest is what makes a human. Attend schools and learn things.
M Vashi Mr Navin, Too many words and not enough said! I think my question now is "Does seperating families (that has internal problem) promises their prosperity? And before you write a long answer think!
Also how dare you call your self practical? when all of your sentences has Ithink, I feel, I assume in it?
Whats the relevance of India's parliamentary structure ???????? "we must incorporate its benefits and not flaws". Even a 4 year old knows that! Give me some facts, statistics like State X split up in year 19XX and 20 years before they split up they had made a,b and c progress but 20 years after they split up they have made 1,2,3,4,5,6 and much more advancements. If you can give me that I am ready to listen to you or else My arguments stands. You just Hush!!!
Also how dare you call your self practical? when all of your sentences has Ithink, I feel, I assume in it?
Whats the relevance of India's parliamentary structure ???????? "we must incorporate its benefits and not flaws". Even a 4 year old knows that! Give me some facts, statistics like State X split up in year 19XX and 20 years before they split up they had made a,b and c progress but 20 years after they split up they have made 1,2,3,4,5,6 and much more advancements. If you can give me that I am ready to listen to you or else My arguments stands. You just Hush!!!
Navin Bhansali Mr Vashi let me tell you that there will be a seperate panel to discuss this issues and moreover if you cant solve internal problems, how can you look for overall development. And you talk about family then let me tell you it is a very different situation. In a family we are able to look after every individual and each is connected to each other. when someone is unhappy we try to solve the problems by mutual discussions and ofcourse If then also we cannot find a solution we have to move on seperate ways. this has happened and will continue to happen. There are many cases were families live separately but that does not make them separate in their hearts. They still meet, talk and communicate with each other but due to some problems like different work, small house we have to live separately. This is a practical approach to a solution. We do not part with our relations and always remain close but just cannot live in the same roof due to some problems like I mentioned before( I am not taking into account those stupid reasons that we witness in serials and movies as they happen rarely 1 out of 25) The same goes for a state when you are unable to develop every part or area, you need to divide so that that area could be developed. I have already said and will still say that small state is better than a large state if we cannot govern it. Or be like Gujarat, being a large state, it has developed all its region equally well. But you will not find Narendra Modi everywhere. If it is for betterment why not do this and take some burden today and live peacefully tomorrow. Moreover india is a federal state and I am sure Mr. Vashi you are aware of the federal structure very well, if not refer wikipedia. This is how our constitution is- a parliamentary system with federal structure. We must incorporate the benefits of a constitution and not its flaws. And if being pratical is assuming things, I am sure you lack some brains.
M Vashi What brian are you using? Because your matter is all philosophical you always think and assume things. Do you know the amount of work effort and complexity that center has to go thru for creating a seperate state? If only half of that is put in advancing that region, people there will be more than happy. Why don't you do the same to your own house. Take the most unhappy person in your family and tell him/her to live independentaly! If that works then say.." n number of states and no harm in doing so...."
Zaman
I agree with Ms.megha ji's column well said that its a quite shocking news from our Govt
but its okey if the Govt announce this news just to keep the situation cool and later every thing goes to (Thanda Basta) cool guys its a
political games.Just wake up and mind our
day to day life.
but its okey if the Govt announce this news just to keep the situation cool and later every thing goes to (Thanda Basta) cool guys its a
political games.Just wake up and mind our
day to day life.
Zaman
We must work to unite every state and every religion,not to devide .Very well done KCR if you are not capable of anything finally you planned for very good drama.
Prashant Patil
This is ridiculous, i am shocked after reading that govt. gives permission to make a new state i.e Telangana. But Congress govt. should take care this in future because there may be more voices or protests going happen for making another state. Just take an example of gorkhaland which is in West Bengal. If govt. goes on making new states there may be possibility in future that there is no concept like united India. Because its been devided into states. This will make our countries growth to affect badly. Congress govt is making all this for vote bank. As we all well aware that congress govt thinks for people.. but the core plan or idea is to grab the vote bank. They are not at all concerned about country growth. Please dont take it in Negative, m not blaming congress purposly but if see our past there are many incidents where in congress took wrong decisions. so this my view..how u all feel..???
Vimal Kumar
This is Unfortunate that people who don't know about Telangana struggle are saying this not a right decision.......I want you to look into the realities and then say why they are fighting for separate state.............If u say that the problem of Telangana can be solved without separation then i would ask you onething..........where were u all these days when people of Telangana were struggling for justice.........I request you to post a comment only if you know the things...........
Sumit Sarkar Vashi i agree with you. And if people believe that after the formation of a new state, their problems will be solved and they will get food,water and education then they are ch***ya's. Jharkhand is an example. Came out of Bihar and same things were promised but nothing was done after it's formation. Please don't divide our country anymore.
M Vashi Ms. Laxmi Nanda,
You just said it. This is all about you and nobody else!
"I might be wrong in your view point, but we people are right for ourselves now, and don't care what others are thinking about US. "
You think that if you are treated unfairly, then its okay to do whatever you like without caring about others!
That says a lot about selfish creaters who have been destroying this planet. Now its come down to a country and a state within it. Whats next Ms.Nanda???
You just said it. This is all about you and nobody else!
"I might be wrong in your view point, but we people are right for ourselves now, and don't care what others are thinking about US. "
You think that if you are treated unfairly, then its okay to do whatever you like without caring about others!
That says a lot about selfish creaters who have been destroying this planet. Now its come down to a country and a state within it. Whats next Ms.Nanda???
Laxmi Nanda @ M Vashi. Not to hurt someone but think of this situation.
If you in a family and they neglect you for your survival and your own parents dont give right food/water/Education for living compared to your siblings then what will you do. Should you die like that forever or fight for survival? If you are discriminated and when the question for your survival comes you will answer the solution.
1) you might be thinking there should be a gentlemans agreement(which is ofcourse there) but nobody follows that.
2) we might fight in the court of Law a very good point but how many years will it take to clear it ? Till then what should we do ?
So please don't come to a conclusion with out knowing what the problems are.
I might be wrong in your view point, but we people are right for ourselves now, and don't care what others are thinking about US.
If you in a family and they neglect you for your survival and your own parents dont give right food/water/Education for living compared to your siblings then what will you do. Should you die like that forever or fight for survival? If you are discriminated and when the question for your survival comes you will answer the solution.
1) you might be thinking there should be a gentlemans agreement(which is ofcourse there) but nobody follows that.
2) we might fight in the court of Law a very good point but how many years will it take to clear it ? Till then what should we do ?
So please don't come to a conclusion with out knowing what the problems are.
I might be wrong in your view point, but we people are right for ourselves now, and don't care what others are thinking about US.
Laxmi Nanda @ Shekar Kamaraju. Sorry this might hurt you, but Some facts you have to know about telangana.
1) The first Reason for asking separate telangana is water, they have a gentleman's agreement to give it in equal proportions which is never done from day one of unification. dont you think that people need water to survive. Water resources (Krishna & Godavari) enter into Andhra pradesh from Telangana.
2) literacy rate during the unification process Andra was 21% and Telangana was < 5%. now the Literacy rates are 70+% in andhra and 10 % in Telangana.
3) Do you know how much revenue does it generate in telangana (more than 1400 Crores) more than other parts.
4) Do you know how many lands have been sold around hyderabad ? more than 200000 acres of land is sold in last 10 years? where did the money go? but they don't give land for graveyards but they sell it for crores. don't we deserve our land
5) Do you know many villages in Telangana doesn't have basic education, Lack transport facility,
6) Do you know have many districts in telangana does not have a government degree colleges? but other places have more than 20 government colleges.
7) You say that they prefer "Sara Dukanam" you are blaming people for that. If people are not educated how can we even think about it?
"Sara Dukanam" Do you know how much of those taxes are sent to other regions for the development it contributes to more than 30% of the taxes that government gets there.
8) We even blame our ministers for t hat.
We dont say KCR is good or its due to him that we got it. It is due to the collective call from the people of telangana they have a clear Idea of what to do now.
9) If we say polliticially correctness and if you have some time please read this SRC about why splitting and separate on this site.
http://demandtelangana.blogspot.com/
Is this the Justice? When we ask for justice which can never be done with these politicians, So people revolted, They are on fire. KCR might be the initiative but Telanganites want it. When someone want it why don't you give them ? This is the result of negligence and over suppress of a region for more than 5 decades.
1) The first Reason for asking separate telangana is water, they have a gentleman's agreement to give it in equal proportions which is never done from day one of unification. dont you think that people need water to survive. Water resources (Krishna & Godavari) enter into Andhra pradesh from Telangana.
2) literacy rate during the unification process Andra was 21% and Telangana was < 5%. now the Literacy rates are 70+% in andhra and 10 % in Telangana.
3) Do you know how much revenue does it generate in telangana (more than 1400 Crores) more than other parts.
4) Do you know how many lands have been sold around hyderabad ? more than 200000 acres of land is sold in last 10 years? where did the money go? but they don't give land for graveyards but they sell it for crores. don't we deserve our land
5) Do you know many villages in Telangana doesn't have basic education, Lack transport facility,
6) Do you know have many districts in telangana does not have a government degree colleges? but other places have more than 20 government colleges.
7) You say that they prefer "Sara Dukanam" you are blaming people for that. If people are not educated how can we even think about it?
"Sara Dukanam" Do you know how much of those taxes are sent to other regions for the development it contributes to more than 30% of the taxes that government gets there.
8) We even blame our ministers for t hat.
We dont say KCR is good or its due to him that we got it. It is due to the collective call from the people of telangana they have a clear Idea of what to do now.
9) If we say polliticially correctness and if you have some time please read this SRC about why splitting and separate on this site.
http://demandtelangana.blogspot.com/
Is this the Justice? When we ask for justice which can never be done with these politicians, So people revolted, They are on fire. KCR might be the initiative but Telanganites want it. When someone want it why don't you give them ? This is the result of negligence and over suppress of a region for more than 5 decades.
Rishi Chand Thota come to any Telangana district and check the growth Kamaraju. List out any developments in Telangana other than Hyderabad.Nagarjuna sagar is in distict Nalgonda but people here are still facing the problem of fluorosis. Do you have any answer for that.
Shekar Kamaraju Yes it can be solved without separating the state. I am a telugu (don't discriminate or guess where I am from) I have lived in all parts of AP. The difference i saw was people in coastal areas have kicked politicians and got their areas developed and have given more importance to education than to food. But in T it is the other way round, given importance to "Sara Dukanam" Now that realisation has come ask the politicians holding their collar what have you done for us? and get the things done. Splitting is never a solution now telengana, 2moro warangal the .... karimnagar...... then what?????? NO I am not emotional..... but use your brain.... papers can say many things your conscious should speak.
M Vashi If you have a problem with your family member due you put a wall across the house? Answer this only if you know the subject matter
Otherwise take your struggle theory and shove it up where the Sun don't shine Mr. Telangana Pundit the Ch***ya!!
Otherwise take your struggle theory and shove it up where the Sun don't shine Mr. Telangana Pundit the Ch***ya!!
Dinesh Mytreya
It is a pity that people who have no knowledge whatsoever about the situation and problems of the Telangana region have begun talking against the formnation of a seperate state.
The movement for a seperate Telangana is not new. It has been there since the past 40 years. Aligning the newly-acquired Nizam state to the Andhra region itself was a big blunder made in those days.
I insist that people who are against the seperate state visit Telangana once and experience the problems first-hand. We have no water to drink, land prices have reached the sky, most of the working class labor consist of the people from telangana. Even after 60 years of independence, the region is still the same. How can we expect development now all of a sudden. Development is possible only through a seperate state.
It should be noted that a separate state is being demanded because the allocation of funds to the region is insufficient and meagre. As ciizens of India, anybody and everybody can come and settle in telangana. Only that they will pay taxes to the state govt. of telangana.
P.S : Donot link this issue with anti-nationalism. I'm from Telangana and I believe I am more patriotic than any oif the persons here. The disintegration of the state is due to the reasons pertaining to development. There is no anti-national motive.
The movement for a seperate Telangana is not new. It has been there since the past 40 years. Aligning the newly-acquired Nizam state to the Andhra region itself was a big blunder made in those days.
I insist that people who are against the seperate state visit Telangana once and experience the problems first-hand. We have no water to drink, land prices have reached the sky, most of the working class labor consist of the people from telangana. Even after 60 years of independence, the region is still the same. How can we expect development now all of a sudden. Development is possible only through a seperate state.
It should be noted that a separate state is being demanded because the allocation of funds to the region is insufficient and meagre. As ciizens of India, anybody and everybody can come and settle in telangana. Only that they will pay taxes to the state govt. of telangana.
P.S : Donot link this issue with anti-nationalism. I'm from Telangana and I believe I am more patriotic than any oif the persons here. The disintegration of the state is due to the reasons pertaining to development. There is no anti-national motive.
Navin Bhansali Mr. Vashi. Dont talk about my school rather join a school on taxes and then comment. If you dont know something then dont comment. Otherwise you make yourself look fool.
Mr. Rahul, I dont know how.US turned into 50 states... I just wanted to say that even with 50 states US is a super power> Morevover I am not opposing large states, but smaller states are better is what I am saying. Gujrat is a big state and if you see all its regions are evenly looked and well developed. But the case is not the same for Andhra due to political instability or many other reasons. So Telengana being a separate state is justified. The reasons has already been discussed If you want, look at the entire blog and read natonal newspapers and you will know. I am thinking about the prosperity and if a separate state can bring about development then what is the harm. I know that the way it was done is not good as other elements in Bengal, Assam and many other states is now revolting for a separate state. But I am sure the centre is not fool as they are much educated and learned then most of us here and they will not be moved by all these movements. They have their brains and only if a separate state can bring about development then only it must be done. That is only possible by discussions and setting panels and centre is just doing that.
Mr. Rahul, I dont know how.US turned into 50 states... I just wanted to say that even with 50 states US is a super power> Morevover I am not opposing large states, but smaller states are better is what I am saying. Gujrat is a big state and if you see all its regions are evenly looked and well developed. But the case is not the same for Andhra due to political instability or many other reasons. So Telengana being a separate state is justified. The reasons has already been discussed If you want, look at the entire blog and read natonal newspapers and you will know. I am thinking about the prosperity and if a separate state can bring about development then what is the harm. I know that the way it was done is not good as other elements in Bengal, Assam and many other states is now revolting for a separate state. But I am sure the centre is not fool as they are much educated and learned then most of us here and they will not be moved by all these movements. They have their brains and only if a separate state can bring about development then only it must be done. That is only possible by discussions and setting panels and centre is just doing that.
Laxmi Nanda @Know the statistics or the revenue of Telangana. it is more than 5000 Crores as stated by SRC. and no way in comparision with the Andhra.
Atleast when they for a separate state the natural resources will be divided equally. and their will be more job oppourtinites for the people from that region.
Do you know where that comes from ?
Coal mines HAve any idea of how much much revenue it creates ?
Atleast when they for a separate state the natural resources will be divided equally. and their will be more job oppourtinites for the people from that region.
Do you know where that comes from ?
Coal mines HAve any idea of how much much revenue it creates ?
Rahul Baweja Come on Navin, America expanded from 13 states to 50 states by conquering more territories. They didn't divide original existing states (except West Virginia). California and Texas are larger than most of the world countries but it doesn't mean that these states are not efficiently controlled. Revenue generation is bottoms-up and not top-down which leads to better handling and less exploitation of the areas.
M Vashi So you think that by getting a seperate state there will be economic growth and people will have basic needs at a resonable price? Which school did you attend?
Where are the taxes going to come from if the area is not economically advanced? It will be grants by the central govt. You think these bloody politicians are going to let you advance the state? Which world do you live in?
Where are the taxes going to come from if the area is not economically advanced? It will be grants by the central govt. You think these bloody politicians are going to let you advance the state? Which world do you live in?
Navin Bhansali I agree with you completely. If by making a seperate state and dividing a large state into suitable parts can bring out development then I think it is a good move. Even America has 50 states which was 13 when she got her independence. So, there is no harm in having a lot number of states because that way it will be possible to analyse the problem more deeply and provide for separate finance from the centre. If you see this is division of state will disturb unity then, I think, you are wrong as a large state has large problems and their are areas which are ignored and hence no development is done in those parts. The same goes for Telengana in Andhra, Vidharva in maharashtra. Even west bengal has such problems but I am not much aware of the disputes of Gorkhas so no comments.
Sagar Potnis
If we see the holistic part , it is correct on the centre's part to award the people of telangna a new state . In democracy , what people want is the main issue and the government has delivered to the petitions and voices of the crowds of that area. Students , activists and their leader , all took various steps ,most of them legitimate as till date they never engaged in mass or hardcore violence .So they deserve it . it shouldnt be much of a problem as its a mutual decision and we dont witness many who are against the motion .
Mitakshara Bhasin
This incident and earlier ones like kandhar etc has proved that political blackmailing of governments in India is possible. The only driving force for giving in to such blackmailing is that political class should not get affected adversely, the common man can go to hell.
Kapil Munshi
Telengana movement was going on for 5 decades,it was always neglected atleast now the new rulers of Telengana should concentrate on development,if few more new states are formed it is not going to pose problems since small states are easy to manage and administer.USA has 50 states and the population is only 1/3 rd of india.Hence no worries if few more states are formed.
Dipankar Roy
Yes its very unfortunate... Too many states is not good, united we stand divided we fall !
Navin Bhansali well this is not dividing a state... but for the betterment of those part and areas of the states which were neglected. If by making a separate state out of those area can improve the situation and development of those parts then I am totally in agreement of such division but only if such things happen. If for religious or cultural reasons, the state is divided then it is wrong. So, see the reasons first and then comment.
Gaurav Vashisht
But i feel the Govt had no choice, they couldn't have left the TRF chief dieing >>>
Rishi Chand Thota Who do not have any such patriotic leaders now. Is there any leader like Lal Bahadur Sastri who resigned as Railway minister for a accident in his tenure.
Kiran Mayi they could easily have.Now gorkhas ask for gorkhaland,punjab will ask for khalistan, sikkim might even want to go out of the country...this only sets a bad precedent, that anyone can hold the govt to ransom...much as i do not appreciate other policies of Indira Gandhi, she certainly was an iron lady in such matters.
Manish Dhingra
Yea, i agree with u its not a good decision, India will soon be disintegrated into a lot of small pieces...
Sunder R Chitturi
Ya I am with you on that! it is a sad day. It is just sending a wrong message to all the hooligans out there. It is a sad day.
Ajay Theegala Well i donno seperation will develop telangana but i am sure that the backwardness in this region will become visible to top authorities who are responsible for development.The way all people speak is as if telangana is just hyderabad....why dont you see other places in this region..you dont find any other city here. its sad the only next big city here is warangal. compare warangal with other cities in andhra you will justify the reson to become seperate...
Laxmi Nanda @ Shekar Kamaraju
Why are you people forcing for united state when a region doesn't want it to be?
So concern for the suffering?
so all you see a 1000 of students and 11 days of fasting from KCR?
don't you see how many farmers are died.
What about the Telangana movement in 1969 when more than 350 Students were killed in Osmania University? Dont you think that was another jallianwala bagh.
In BasherBagh do you know how many farmers were shot died (more than 30).
And if we people do it once for sake of ourselves you find trouble. There was no one to talk when we had to suffer.
Why are you people forcing for united state when a region doesn't want it to be?
So concern for the suffering?
so all you see a 1000 of students and 11 days of fasting from KCR?
don't you see how many farmers are died.
What about the Telangana movement in 1969 when more than 350 Students were killed in Osmania University? Dont you think that was another jallianwala bagh.
In BasherBagh do you know how many farmers were shot died (more than 30).
And if we people do it once for sake of ourselves you find trouble. There was no one to talk when we had to suffer.
Rishi Chand Thota Mr. Shekar What about the incidents happenin in Andhra and Rayalseema since yesterday. Congress did not give a chance to JAgan when there is a crisis of party splitting after YSR's death . do they easily give up for TRS. Think 100 times before posting a comment, thse politics are out of our understanding.
Shekar Kamaraju Yes, i agree with you govt has succumbed to blackmailing of of a few thousand hooligans calling themselves students. If they are really students then god save India. And so called leader KCR how could he stand up after 11 days of fasting ???? Its a big question mark. Its all farce and fake. As some one mentioned BJP gave up to TALIBAN and CONGRESS to TRS (what a coincidence both start with "T")
Navin Bhansali the way it was done is really sad.... but looking into the reasons why telengana should be a separate state... I am sure it will benefit the state and the country as a whole. Even Bihar, UP and MP was divided but such violence and fasting didn't occur. And I dont feel that having n number of states is bad. Infact a small state can be progressed better than a normal large state which has so many problems that it cannot or sometimes don't want to look after the development of certain areas. This is what is happening to Telengana and so I think creating a new state is no harm if by this it can prosper and develop by getting financial help from centre as every states in India get. But if only prosperity for the region is a concern, I assume, creation of a new state is no harm. Seeing this, some elements may try to blackmail the govt. in division of more states just because of religious or cultural bias and this should not happen. We must use brains and do things that may help in prosperity of a country but not that divide our motherland. I think people at the centre are intelligent enough not to get carried away by such practices ad keep on dividing regions for no useful and unworthy reasons.
Shruti Srivastava they have not just divided the state but are also destroying the legal system in the state and the Country. Students destroying the public property, calling bandhs, disturbing the daily life of the common public, how sick. .If Mr KCR was really upon fast unto death, he shouldnt have even got hospitalized,.... how much ever the ppl forced him to . May b he was forced to get hospitalized, but could have rejected it , the way he rejected to break his fast. Sab Nautanki .ab to inke bhi putle banenge, Jai Jai kar hogi.. . samjahte hai herogiri karke , Raj karenge .. Very very sad
Basharath Peer Yes its a message, that u can keep fast and force Indian Govt. to cut India into as many parts as u want !
Its really sad
Its really sad
